QUESTION 231
person Asked by .
bookmark_add
Describe the WHO analgesic ladder and its application to acute postoperative pain [3]. Explain the pharmacology of
description
Clinical Response
"patient-controlled analgesia (PCA) — standard parameters, opioid selection and safety features [4]. Outline a multimodal
analgesic strategy for major abdominal surgery [3].
⚙
Core Concept
Acute postoperative pain is undertreated in 50% of surgical patients — with consequences including immobility, atelectasis, DVT, poor wound healing, and
progression to chronic post-surgical pain (CPSP). A multimodal approach (combining analgesics with different mechanisms to achieve additive/synergistic
analgesia with reduced individual drug doses and side effects) is the evidence-based standard.
(WHO analgesic ladder 1986; Kehlet H — multimodal
analgesia; PROSPECT guidelines; Rawal N — PCA pharmacology)
A. WHO Analgesic Ladder — Application to Acute Pain
3 marks
WHO ladder (1986) — originally for cancer pain, now adapted for acute postoperative pain:
Step 1 (mild pain — VAS 1–3/10):
non-opioid analgesics — paracetamol (1g QDS IV or oral) ± NSAIDs/COX-2 inhibitors (ibuprofen 400 mg TDS,
diclofenac 75 mg BD, celecoxib 200 mg BD — contraindicated in: renal impairment, peptic ulcer disease, cardiovascular disease, post-GI surgery,
pregnancy >30 weeks)
Step 2 (moderate pain — VAS 4–6/10):
weak opioid ± non-opioid — codeine 30–60 mg 4-hourly (hepatically metabolised to morphine via CYP2D6 —
ultra-rapid metabolisers [10% of Caucasians] → toxic morphine levels; poor metabolisers → no analgesia; therefore codeine is unpredictable; tramadol
50–100 mg QDS — dual mechanism: weak μ agonist + SNRI; serotonin syndrome risk with SSRIs/MAOIs)
Step 3 (severe pain — VAS 7–10/10):
strong opioid ± non-opioid ± adjuvants — morphine, oxycodone, fentanyl, hydromorphone; PCA (see below); IV
patient-titrated loading boluses (titrate 2–5 mg morphine IV every 5 min until VAS ≤3)
Adaptation for acute postoperative pain:
the WHO ladder is used in REVERSE for acute pain (Step 3 first, then stepping DOWN as pain improves) — this is
the ""reverse ladder"" concept; pre-operatively: anticipate pain intensity and plan multimodal strategy rather than reacting to pain after it occurs (pro-active vs
reactive analgesia)
Adjuvants at any step:
gabapentinoids (pregabalin 150 mg BD, gabapentin 300 mg TDS — ↓ central sensitisation, ↓ opioid requirements, ↓ PONV; most
useful in neuropathic or chronic pain component); ketamine sub-anaesthetic infusion (0.1–0.2 mg/kg/h — NMDA antagonist, prevents central sensitisation,
reduces opioid requirements); α₂ agonists (clonidine, dexmedetomidine — spinal and systemic analgesia)
B. Patient-Controlled Analgesia (PCA) Pharmacology
4 marks
PCA rationale:
analgesic requirements vary 5-fold between patients of the same weight undergoing the same procedure (due to genetic variability in opioid
metabolism, receptor sensitivity, pain threshold, anxiety, pre-operative opioid tolerance); a fixed-dose nurse-administered schedule cannot accommodate this
variability; PCA allows the patient to self-administer small boluses when pain exceeds their individual threshold → rapid titration to individual analgesic
requirement
Standard PCA parameters (morphine IV):
Parameter
Standard
Value
(Morphine)
Rationale
Bolus dose
1 mg
morphine
(range 0.5–
2.5 mg)
Small enough that a single extra dose does not cause respiratory depression; large enough to provide meaningful analgesia; in elderly
>70: 0.5–1 mg; opioid-tolerant patients may need 2–2.5 mg
Lockout
interval
5 minutes
Time to peak effect of IV morphine (5–10 min); prevents stacking before previous dose has taken effect; shorter lockout → ↑ overdose
risk; longer → ↑ inadequate analgesia
Background
(continuous)
infusion
NOT routinely
recommended
(0 mg/h)
Background infusion → ↑ opioid accumulation during sleep → ↑ respiratory depression risk (ISMP warning); reserved for opioid-
tolerant patients (chronic opioid users) — match their baseline opioid requirements as background; children PCA-by-proxy: nurse or
parent presses button → ↑ risk of overdose — NOT safe without HCA (healthcare professional-activated)
1-hour limit
(or 4-hour
limit)
10–20 mg/h
(cumulative
safety limit)
Prevents excessive cumulative dosing; alerts nursing staff to reassess patient
Concentration
Morphine 1
mg/mL
Standard concentration; errors occur with non-standard concentrations
Opioid selection for PCA:
Morphine — standard; active metabolite morphine-6-glucuronide (M6G) accumulates in renal failure → prolonged sedation; hydrophilic → slower onset
(10–15 min) → higher bolus requirements
Fentanyl — lipophilic → faster onset (5–7 min) → better titration; no active metabolites; preferred in renal failure; bolus 20–25 mcg (lockout 5 min)
Oxycodone — intermediate lipophilicity; active metabolite oxymorphone; oral bioavailability 60–87% → oral oxycodone PCA available in some centres
Hydromorphone — 5–7× more potent than morphine; active 3-glucuronide metabolite (accumulates in renal failure); bolus 0.2–0.4 mg
PCA safety features:
anti-reflux one-way valve (prevents siphoning of opioid into IV fluid bag); anti-tamper device; programmable lockout (cannot override);
nurse override key (for loading dose); alarmed when reservoir low; dedicated PCA IV line (do NOT co-infuse other IV drugs — bolus of flush pushes PCA
opioid → inadvertent overdose); monitoring: sedation score (Ramsay or RASS) + RR + SpO₂ (continuous overnight in high-risk patients)
C. Multimodal Analgesic Strategy — Major Abdominal Surgery
3 marks
Timing
Intervention
Rationale
Pre-operative
Celecoxib 400 mg PO + gabapentin 600 mg PO (pre-emptive analgesia); patient education and
expectations; mark and plan regional technique; consent for epidural or TAP block
Pre-emptive analgesia: giving analgesics
before surgical injury → prevents central
sensitisation before it occurs (more effective
than treating established sensitisation post-op)
Intraoperative
Thoracic epidural (T6–T9 for upper abdominal; T9–T12 for lower) + TIVA propofol-remifentanil OR LA
wound infiltration/TAP block at end; IV paracetamol 1g at induction; IV ketorolac 15–30 mg at wound
closure; sub-anaesthetic ketamine 0.3 mg/kg/h infusion during surgery; dexamethasone 8 mg at
induction (PONV + reduces pain); tranexamic acid (if applicable — ↓ blood loss)
Epidural provides best post-op analgesia for
open abdominal surgery; TAP block for
laparoscopic; ketamine infusion → reduces
opioid consumption 25–40% and PONV
Postoperative
Epidural infusion (bupivacaine 0.1% + fentanyl 2 mcg/mL) at 6–12 mL/h (if epidural in situ) OR PCA
morphine/oxycodone (if no epidural); regular paracetamol 1g QDS; regular celecoxib 200 mg BD (if no
contraindication — avoid in anastomotic bowel surgery — anastomotic leak risk); gabapentin 300 mg
BD; breakthrough: oramorph 5–10 mg oral or morphine 2.5 mg IV; VAS assessment 4-hourly
Regular non-opioid base → reduces opioid
requirements 20–40%; epidural significantly
reduces pulmonary complications, ileus, and
hospital stay in open abdominal surgery
(Kehlet 1999)
★
Examiner's Pearl
WHO ladder adapted for acute pain: use in REVERSE (Step 3 first → step down). PCA standard: morphine 1 mg bolus, 5 min lockout, NO routine background infusion
(↑ respiratory depression risk during sleep). Renal failure: avoid morphine (M6G accumulation) → use fentanyl. Multimodal strategy for major abdominal: epidural (best
for open) + paracetamol + NSAID/COX-2 + gabapentin + ketamine infusion + dexamethasone = reduces opioid requirements 40–50%. Pre-emptive analgesia: given
BEFORE surgical injury → prevents central sensitisation.
References:
Kehlet H, Dahl JB. The value of ""multimodal"" or ""balanced analgesia"" in postoperative pain treatment (Anesth Analg 1993;77:1048-1056). Macintyre PE. Safety and efficacy of
patient-controlled analgesia (Br J Anaesth 2001;87:36-46). WHO. Cancer Pain Relief, 1986. Miller RD et al. Miller's Anaesthesia, 9th Ed, Chapter 64."