Describe the PADIS 2018 guidelines framework for ICU pain, agitation, delirium, immobility, and sleep. Outline the RASS scale, the Spontaneous Awakening Trial (SAT), sedation targets, and the CAM-ICU delirium assessment. Discuss the evidence for light sedation over deep sedation.
Domain Key Recommendation Assessment Tool
P — Pain Assess pain routinely; use analgesia-first approach (treat pain before sedation); non-opioid NRS (Numeric Rating Scale 0–10) for analgesics first (paracetamol, NSAIDs if appropriate, regional techniques); opioids titrated to communicative; BPS (Behavioural Pain Scale) or VAS/NRS ≤3/10 CPOT (Critical-Care Pain Observation Tool) for non-communicative
A — Agitation Light sedation target (RASS 0 to −2) preferred over deep sedation (RASS −3 to −5); reduces RASS (Richmond Agitation-Sedation Scale −5 to (Sedation) ventilator days, ICU stay, delirium; dexmedetomidine preferred over benzodiazepines for non- +4) deeply sedated patients
D — Delirium Routine delirium screening; multicomponent non-pharmacological bundle (reorientation, sleep CAM-ICU (Confusion Assessment Method for hygiene, early mobilisation, family involvement, natural lighting); avoid benzodiazepines (delirium ICU) — validated for intubated patients; takes <2 risk); antipsychotics (haloperidol) do not reliably prevent delirium but may treat hyperactive minutes delirium symptoms
I — Immobility Early mobilisation within 24–48 hours of ICU admission where safe; reduces ICU-acquired ABCDEF bundle: Awaken + Breathe + (Rehabilitation) weakness, delirium, and ventilator days; structured progressive rehabilitation (passive ROM → Coordinate + Delirium + Early mobility + Family active assisted → active → sitting → standing → walking)
S — Sleep Promote sleep-wake cycling; minimise nighttime interruptions; reduce light and noise; avoid Richards-Campbell Sleep Questionnaire (RCSQ) benzodiazepines and propofol for sleep (both suppress N3 and REM sleep); melatonin or for patient self-report dexmedetomidine may promote more physiological sleep architecture
Score Level Description +4 Combative Overtly combative, violent, immediate danger to staff +3 Very agitated Pulls or removes tubes/catheters; aggressive +2 Agitated Frequent non-purposeful movement, fights ventilator +1 Restless Anxious but movements not aggressive or vigorous 0 Alert and calm Spontaneously alert and calm — TARGET for most ICU patients −1 Drowsy Not fully alert; sustained awakening (eye opening >10 seconds to voice) −2 Light sedation Brief awakening to voice (eye opening <10 seconds); acceptable light sedation target −3 Moderate sedation Movement or eye opening to voice; no eye contact −4 Deep sedation No response to voice; movement or eye opening to physical stimulation −5 Unarousable No response to voice or physical stimulation
Daily SAT (Kress JB — NEJM 2000; Ely EW NEJM 2008): all sedation stopped (or significantly reduced) every morning for up to 4 hours to assess the patient's neurological status and wakefulness; if the patient demonstrates adequate spontaneous breathing, awakens appropriately, and does not require immediate re-sedation for agitation/self-extubation → proceed to SBT; Ely NEJM 2008 (SAT + SBT): combining daily SAT with daily SBT reduced 1-year mortality by 14% and reduced ventilator days by 3 days vs SBT alone
SAT safety screen: active seizures; active alcohol withdrawal; open abdomen; FiO₂ >0.5 or PEEP >8 (too sick for SAT); actively receiving therapeutic neuromuscular blockade; resting agitation before SAT (cannot safely stop sedation in already-agitated patient)
Failed SAT: agitation, anxiety, pain, RR >35, SpO₂ <88%, new arrhythmia or haemodynamic instability during the SAT → restart sedation at half the previous dose
Four CAM-ICU features (ALL four must be assessed):
Feature 1: ACUTE ONSET OR FLUCTUATING COURSE — new change or fluctuation in RASS score or GCS within the last 24 hours? (Yes → proceed)
Feature 2: INATTENTION — "Squeeze my hand every time you hear the letter A" test (reading a series of letters including multiple As); errors in squeezing on non-A letters or not squeezing on A letters = positive; OR picture recognition test in non-English speakers
Feature 3: ALTERED LEVEL OF CONSCIOUSNESS — current RASS other than 0; if yes → CAM-ICU positive (delirium without needing Feature 4)
Feature 4: DISORGANISED THINKING — can patient answer 4 simple yes/no questions correctly? Can patient follow 2 commands? CAM-ICU positive = delirium if Features 1 + 2 present AND either Feature 3 OR Feature 4 is positive
Types of delirium: hyperactive (agitated, pulling lines, fighting ventilator — obvious); hypoactive (quiet, withdrawn, blunted — frequently missed; worse prognosis than hyperactive); mixed (fluctuating between both)
Management: non-pharmacological first (reorientation, early mobilisation, sleep hygiene, family presence, remove unnecessary lines and catheters); pharmacological: haloperidol 0.5–2 mg IV BD (most widely used; evidence weak for prevention but useful for symptom management of hyperactive delirium); dexmedetomidine (MENDS trial — less delirium than midazolam; SEDCOM — less delirium than midazolam)
Multiple RCTs (Kress NEJM 2000, Girard NEJM 2008, Strøm BJA 2010) consistently demonstrate: light sedation (RASS 0 to −2) vs deep sedation (RASS −3 to −5) produces: shorter mechanical ventilation duration (2–3 days fewer); shorter ICU stay; fewer delirium days; LOWER 1-year mortality in some analyses; no increase in patient recall of unpleasant experiences (patients sedated to RASS −2 do not remember being ventilated in the vast majority of cases) Analgesia-first approach (Strøm BJA 2010): protocol of morphine boluses for pain + paracetamol + no background sedation → significantly less sedation exposure, shorter MV time, and no increase in patient distress or self-extubation vs standard propofol-based sedation; analgesia-first is now endorsed by PADIS 2018 as the foundation of ICU pain and sedation management