Describe the indications, technique, waveform interpretation, and complications of invasive arterial pressure monitoring. Compare CVP, PAC, PiCCO, and TOE as tools for haemodynamic monitoring. Define goal-directed therapy (GDT) and the OPTIMISE trial evidence.
Indications: anticipated haemodynamic instability (major vascular surgery, cardiac surgery, severe haemorrhage risk); need for frequent ABG sampling; patients requiring vasopressor/inotrope titration; severe hypertension; difficult-to-measure NIBP (obesity, arrhythmias); phaeochromocytoma; deliberate hypotension
Technique — radial artery (most common): Allen's test (optional — confirm dual circulation); 20G cannula; Seldinger or direct technique; sterile preparation; connect to non-compliant pressure tubing + transducer (compliant tubing distorts the waveform — "damping"); transducer levelled at the phlebostatic axis (4th
ICS, mid-axillary line) and zeroed to atmospheric pressure
Waveform components: upstroke = systole (rate reflects LV contractility); peak = systolic BP; dicrotic notch = aortic valve closure (separates systole from diastole); downslope = diastolic runoff; trough = diastolic BP; area under the curve = MAP; pulse pressure variation during IPPV indicates fluid responsiveness
Complications: haematoma; arterial occlusion (more likely with smaller arteries, prolonged cannulation, haematoma); distal ischaemia; infection; accidental intra-arterial drug injection (catastrophic — label all arterial lines prominently)
CVP measures right atrial pressure (normally 0–8 mmHg); the waveform contains: a wave (atrial contraction); c wave (tricuspid valve closure); x descent (atrial relaxation); v wave (venous filling with closed tricuspid valve); y descent (tricuspid valve opens → passive ventricular filling)
Limitations as a fluid responsiveness marker: CVP does NOT reliably predict fluid responsiveness in clinical practice; Marik (Chest 2008; systematic review of 24 studies): CVP was not correlated with blood volume and could not predict haemodynamic response to a fluid challenge; patients with low CVP may or may not respond to fluid; patients with high CVP may respond; CVP is influenced by venous tone, intrathoracic pressure, RV compliance, and many other factors independent of volume status
Current role: CVP provides information about right heart function and filling; useful for comparison over time; useful for CVP waveform analysis (cannon a waves in complete heart block, blunt y descent in tamponade); still useful to guide vasopressor vs fluid therapy in certain scenarios; SHOULD NOT be the sole guide for fluid resuscitation
Parameter Normal Value Clinical Interpretation PAWP (pulmonary artery 6–12 mmHg Left atrial filling pressure; PAWP >18 mmHg → cardiogenic pulmonary oedema; PAWP <8 with hypotension → wedge pressure) hypovolaemia or vasodilatory shock Cardiac Output 4–8 L/min Low CO → cardiogenic or obstructive shock; high CO + low SVR → septic, anaphylactic, hepatic failure (thermodilution) SVR (systemic vascular 800–1200 Low SVR = vasodilatory shock (sepsis); high SVR = cardiogenic shock (reflexive vasoconstriction) resistance) dynes·sec/cm⁵ Mixed venous O₂ sat (SvO₂) 65–75% Low SvO₂ (<65%) → inadequate O₂ delivery or ↑ O₂ extraction (anaemia, high output demand); high SvO₂ (>80%) → distributive shock (O₂ not extracted — shunting) The PAC's clinical utility has been questioned by multiple randomised trials (PACMAN, ESCAPE) showing no mortality benefit and possible harm from its complications; it retains specific roles in: complex cardiac surgery (post-cardiopulmonary bypass haemodynamic management), severe pulmonary hypertension assessment, refractory shock characterisation when less invasive measures are insufficient
Oesophageal Doppler Monitor (ODM): a small Doppler probe placed in the oesophagus (at 35–40 cm from the incisors) and positioned adjacent to the descending aorta; measures aortic blood flow velocity using a 4 MHz Doppler signal; allows continuous, real-time assessment of: stroke volume (SV), cardiac output (CO), corrected flow time (FTc — a surrogate for preload), and peak velocity (a surrogate for LV contractility); non-invasive and minimally invasive alternative to PAC for CO measurement
Goal-Directed Therapy (GDT) using ODM: algorithm-based fluid and vasopressor management targeting specific physiological endpoints: fluid challenges of 200–250 mL crystalloid/colloid → assess if SV increases >10% (fluid responsive → give more fluid) or <10% (non-responsive → stop fluid, consider vasopressor or inotrope); targets: FTc 0.35–0.40 seconds; SV index >35 mL/m²; CO optimisation OPTIMISE trial (Pearse RM, BMJ 2014; n=734 high-risk major GI surgery patients): ODM-guided GDT (stroke volume optimisation using colloid challenges) vs standard care; result: ODM-GDT significantly reduced the rate of postoperative complications (36.6% vs 43.4%) without increasing hospital mortality; meta-analysis including OPTIMISE confirms GDT reduces postoperative complications and hospital length of stay in high-risk surgical patients
Dynamic fluid responsiveness markers: SVV (stroke volume variation during IPPV >13% = fluid responsive); PPV (pulse pressure variation >13% = fluid responsive); PLR test (raise legs → ↑ CO ≥10% = fluid responsive) — these are superior to CVP/PAWP for predicting fluid responsiveness
PiCCO (Pulse Index Continuous Cardiac Output) uses transpulmonary thermodilution (cold saline injected via CVC; measured via a thermistor in the femoral artery) for intermittent CO measurement calibrating a continuous pulse contour analysis algorithm; provides: CO (continuous); GEDVI (global end-diastolic volume index — a volumetric preload marker superior to CVP); EVLWI (extravascular lung water index — measures pulmonary oedema quantitatively; EVLWI >10 mL/kg = pulmonary oedema; >14 mL/kg = severe oedema); SVV (continuous fluid responsiveness marker) Particularly useful in ARDS management (EVLWI allows quantification and monitoring of pulmonary oedema), post-cardiac surgery, and complex septic shock where distinguishing between fluid overload and under-resuscitation is difficult